James Hardie vs. LP SmartSide: Which Siding Is Right for Utah Homes?

siding salt lake city

When you want to upgrade your home in Utah, the first thing many homeowners consider is the siding. Choosing a good material is imperative for Utah property owners because the weather can be extreme, demanding durable and resilient materials. When considering exterior remodeling in Salt Lake City or surrounding areas, popular options include James Hardie (fiber cement) and LP SmartSide (engineered wood). Both have distinct advantages and are proudly offered by the experts from Gutter Works. Learn more about how they can protect your home year-round.

Quick Breakdown: James Hardie Vs. LP Smartside 

If you’re considering fiber cement siding in Salt Lake City, James Hardie siding would be a top consideration. It’s a unique product that is made from a blend of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. It’s ideal for anyone who values protection against Utah’s harsh environment and unpredictable weather patterns. LP SmartSide Siding an engineered wood product treated with SmartGuard® technology, which enhances its resistance to moisture, termites, and fungal decay.

What goals do both products have in common? They both mimic the look and feel of authentic wood but choosing one over the other is based on your preferences, budget, and desired maintenance level. Below those differences are explained in more detail to give you an idea of what to expect for your Utah home.

Material And Durability: What’s Best For Your Utah Home?

No matter which product you select, homeowners want to know they have something tough to stand up against Utah’s climate. Jame’s Hardie siding is made of fiber cement, which acts as a natural barrier against pests and mold. It’s also a good pick if you want to stay comfortable during hot summers and cold winters. LP SmartSide siding is an engineered wood product that offers excellent resistance to impacts and harsh weather. Its SmartGuard® treatment provides enhanced protection against moisture and termites. However, engineered wood can still be susceptible to moisture damage if not properly maintained. It’s essential to ensure proper installation and maintenance to maximize its lifespan.

What To Expect With Installation

If you’re searching for engineered wood siding in Salt Lake City, LP SmartSide Siding is lighter and easy to install. It’s popular for homeowners who want a quicker siding installation and lower costs. James Hardie siding requires specialized tools and a trained crew for installation, making the process more involved. It’s heavier, and its precise installation is crucial for optimal performance and warranty validity. Both products are good for optimal performance, but you can expect Hardie siding to take longer to install because of the heavier material and details it needs for proper installation.

Aesthetic Appeal: Style and Customization for Your Home

James Hardie and LP SmartSide sidings offer homeowners a wide array of aesthetic choices, which gives you more control on how you want your home to look.. They  mimic the natural beauty of wood, providing various wood-grain textures and different color choices. James Hardie stands out with its ColorPlus® Technology. This is a factory-applied, baked-on finish that offers vibrant, long-lasting color that reduces the likelihood of fading. LP SmartSide siding also has diverse aesthetic options. However, it does require repainting after installation unless a prefinished product is specifically chosen. This provides flexibility for custom color choices, but also adds an additional step to the installation process.

Lifespan Of Each Product

If you’re considering James Hardie Siding Installation in Salt Lake City, the main point of concern for most property owners is how long the product will last. One of the perks of James Hardie siding is its virtually maintenance-free. Repainting only typically needs done every 15 years or so. Although there is a higher upfront cost, it could last up to 50 years or more depending on how well it’s cared for.

If you’re looking for LP SmartSide Siding Installation in Salt Lake City, it could be considered as a top alternative to James Hardie siding. Although you shouldn’t expect it to last as long as long, it can still have a lifespan of up to 20-30 years, depending on how well it’s maintained.

Cost and Reputation: How Do They Compare? 

Exterior remodeling in Salt Lake City is a considerable investment, and it’s hard to go wrong with either product. Fiber cement siding generally has a higher upfront cost than engineered wood siding. However, the long-term value and lower maintenance of James Hardie can offset the initial investment. LP SmartSide siding typically offers a lower upfront cost, making it an attractive option for homeowners working with a tighter budget.

At The Gutter Works, we wouldn’t put our name behind any products we didn’t believe in. You can have peace of mind knowing each choice would be a great pick for your home. James Hardie is nationally recognized for quality and performance. Also, LP SmartSide is gaining popularity and offers impressive warranties.

Which One Is Right For You? 

Consider James Hardie if: 

  • Prioritize long-term durability and low maintenance.
  • Desire a non-combustible material for added fire protection.
  • Are willing to invest more upfront for long-term value.

Consider LP SmartSide if you:

  • Seek a more budget-friendly option.
  • Prefer a lighter material that’s easier to install.
  • Don’t mind periodic maintenance and repainting.

Make The Best Decision: Talk To The Gutter Works

We are expert siding contractors in Salt Lake City. We professionally install James Hardie and LP Smartside Siding and consider your needs and budget. Contact us today to schedule a free siding estimate and take the first step toward enhancing your home’s exterior.

Request A Quote Today

Reach Us

Email :

Phone :

Siding Systems, Inc. and The Gutter Works has been helping the residents of the Wasatch Front enhance and beautify the outside of their homes for more than 30 years.